Combined Regression

knitr::opts_chunk$set(echo = TRUE)


It is considered bad statistical practice to dichotomise continuous outcomes, but some applications require predicted probabilities rather than predicted values. To obtain predicted values, we recommend to model the original continuous outcome with linear regression. To obtain predicted probabilities, we recommend not to model the artificial binary outcome with logistic regression, but to model the original continuous outcome and the artificial binary outcome with combined regression.


Install the current release from CRAN:


Or install the development version from GitHub:


Then load and attach the package:



We simulate data for $n$ samples and $p$ features, in a high-dimensional setting ($p \gg n$). The matrix $\boldsymbol{X}$ with $n$ rows and $p$ columns represents the features, and the vector $\boldsymbol{y}$ of length $n$ represents the continuous outcome.

n <- 100; p <- 500
X <- matrix(rnorm(n*p),nrow=n,ncol=p)
beta <- rbinom(n=p,size=1,prob=0.05)
y <- rnorm(n=n,mean=X%*%beta)

We use the function cornet for modelling the original continuous outcome and the artificial binary outcome. The argument cutoff splits the samples into two groups, those with an outcome less than or equal to the cutoff, and those with an outcome greater than the cutoff.

model <- cornet(y=y,cutoff=0,X=X)

The function coef returns the estimated coefficients. The first column is for the linear model (beta), and the second column is for the logistic model (gamma). The first row includes the estimated intercepts, and the other rows include the estimated slopes.

coef <- coef(model)

The function predict returns fitted values for training data, or predicted values for testing data. The argument newx specifies the feature matrix. The output is a matrix with one column for each model.

predict <- predict(model,newx=X)

The function cv.cornet measures the predictive performance of combined regression by nested cross-validation, in comparison with logistic regression.


Here we observe that combined regression outperforms logistic regression (lower logistic deviance), and that logistic regression is only slightly better than the intercept-only model.


Rauschenberger A, and Glaab E (2021). "Predicting artificial binary outcomes from high-dimensional data". Manuscript in preparation.

Try the cornet package in your browser

Any scripts or data that you put into this service are public.

cornet documentation built on April 19, 2021, 9:07 a.m.