plot_effect: Partial-dependence effects and plots

In spaMM: Mixed-Effect Models, with or without Spatial Random Effects

Partial-dependence effects and plots

Description

The function pdep_effects evaluates, and the function plot_effects plots, partial-dependence effects.

pdep_effects evaluates the effect of a given fixed-effect variable, as (by default, the average of) predicted values on the response scale, over the empirical distribution of all other fixed-effect variables in the data, and of inferred random effects. This can be seen as the result of an experiment where specific treatments (given values of the focal variable) are applied over all conditions defined by the other fixed effects and by the inferred random effects. Thus, apparent dependencies induced by associations between predictor variables are avoided (see Friedman, 2001, from which the name “partial dependence plot” is taken; or Hastie et al., 2009, Section 10.13.2). This also avoids biases of possible alternative ways of plotting effects. In particular, such biases occur if the response link is not identity, and if averaging is performed on the linear-predictor scale or when other variables are set to some conventional value other than its average.

pdep_effects also compute intervals of the type defined by its intervals argument (by default, prediction intervals) and of nominal coverage defined by the level argument (it may make particular sense to choose a level<0.95 to better visualize effects). By default, it returns a data frame of average values of point predictions and interval bounds for each value of the focal variable (so the intervals may briefly be described as mean prediction intervals, for want of better), but it can also return lists of all predictions.

A plot function is available for numeric or factor predictors: plot_effects calls pdep_effects and produces a simple plot (using only base graphic functions) of its results, including prediction bands representing the two average one-sided widths of intervals. The last section of the Examples shows how to obtain more elaborate plots including the same information using ggplot2.

If added to the plot, the raw data may appear to depart from the partial-dependence predictions, since the data are a priori affected by the associations between variables which the predictions free themselves from. An adapted plot of fit residuals may be then be more useful, and the Examples also show how it can be performed.

Usage

pdep_effects(object, focal_var, newdata = object$data, length.out = 20, 
             focal_values=NULL, level=0.95, levels = NULL, 
             intervals = "predVar", indiv = FALSE, ...)
plot_effects(object, focal_var, newdata = object$data, focal_values=NULL, 
             effects = NULL, xlab = focal_var, ylab = NULL, 
             rgb.args = col2rgb("blue"), add = FALSE,  ylim=NULL, ...)

Arguments

object	An object of class HLfit, as returned by the fitting functions in spaMM.
focal_var	Character string: the name of the predictor variable whose effect is to be represented. The variable must be numeric for plot_effects but not necessarily so for pdep_effects.
newdata	If non-NULL, a data frame passed to predict.HLfit, whose documentation should be consulted for further details.
effects	If non-NULL, a data frame to substitute to the one produced by default by pdep_effects.
xlab	If non-NULL, a character string: X-axis label for the plot.
ylab	If non-NULL, a character string: Y-axis label for the plot.
ylim	The plot's ylim argument. Default is based on the (0.025,0.975) quantiles of the response.
rgb.args	Color control arguments, in the format produced by col2rgb.
add	Boolean: whether to add graphic elements of a previous plot produced by plot_effects
length.out	Integer: for a numeric predictor variable, this controls the number of values at which predictions are evaluated. By default, predictions are made at regular intervals over the range of the predictor variable. If length.out=0, predictions are made for the actual values of the focal predictor in the data. The default behaviour is also overriden by using focal_values, in which case predictions are evaluated at the given focal_values (as if length.out=0), unless a non-zero length.out is also specified. In the latter case, predictions are evaluated at regular intervals over the range of focal_values.
intervals, level	Passed to predict.HLfit, whose documentation should be consulted for further details.
focal_values, levels	focal_values may be used to specify the values of the focal variable at which predictions are evaluated. For factor variables, levels is an older implementation of this control, and is now redundant.
indiv	Boolean: whether to return all predictions given the values of other predictors in the newdata, or only their means.
...	Further arguments passed by plot_effects to pdep_effects, or by pdep_effects to predict.HLfit.

Value

For pdep_effects, a nested list, or a data frame storing values of the focal_var, average point predictions pointp and bounds low and up of intervals, depending on the indiv argument. When indiv is TRUE, each sublist contains vectors for pointp, low and up.

For plot_effects, the same value, returned invisibly.

References

J.H. Friedman (2001). Greedy Function Approximation: A Gradient Boosting Machine. Annals of Statistics 29(5):1189-1232.

J. Friedman, T. Hastie and R. Tibshirani (2009) The Elements of Statistical Learning, 2nd ed. Springer.

Examples

data("scotlip")
hlcor <- HLCor(cases~I(prop.ag/10) +adjacency(1|gridcode)+offset(log(expec)),
           adjMatrix=Nmatrix,family=poisson(),data=scotlip) 
plot_effects(hlcor,focal_var="prop.ag",ylim=c(0,max(scotlip$cases)))  
points(cases~prop.ag, data=scotlip, col="blue",pch=20)

# Impose specific values of a numeric predictor using 'focal_values':
plot_effects(hlcor, focal_var="prop.ag", focal_values=1:5)

### Adding 'partial residuals' [residuals relative to predict(<fit object>),
###  but plotted relative to pdep_effects() predictions]:

# One first needs predictions for actual values of the predictor variable,
# provided by pdep_effects(.,length.out=0L):
#
pdep_points <- pdep_effects(hlcor,focal_var="prop.ag",length.out=0L)

# Rename for easy prediction for each observation, and add the residuals 
# of the actual fit, using the default residuals() i.e. deviance ones: 
#
rownames(pdep_points) <- pdep_points$focal_var
pdep_res <- pdep_points[paste(hlcor$data$prop.ag),"pointp"] + 
              residuals(hlcor)

points(x = hlcor$data$prop.ag, y = pdep_res, col = "red", pch = 20)

## Not run:  

## Plotting pdep-effects for different categories, using ggplot.
library(ggplot2)

data("Gryphon")
tmp <- na.omit(Gryphon_df)
spfit <- spaMM::fitme(TARSUS ~ BWT*sex, data = tmp)

tmp$sex <- "1"
pdep_1 <- pdep_effects(spfit,"BWT", newdata=tmp, level=qnorm(0.75))
#                   qnorm(0.75)  to get the so-called 'probable error'.
tmp$sex <- "2"
pdep_2 <- pdep_effects(spfit,"BWT", newdata=tmp, level=qnorm(0.75))
pdep_1$sex <- "1" ; pdep_2$sex <- "2"  
pdep <- rbind(pdep_1,pdep_2)

ggplot(pdep,aes(y = pointp , x = focal_var ,col = sex, fill=sex)) + geom_point() +
  geom_ribbon(aes(ymin = low, ymax = up), alpha = 0.3) + xlab("BWT") +
  ylab("TARSUS")



## End(Not run)

spaMM documentation built on June 22, 2024, 9:48 a.m.