STR markers in forensic genetics

library(knitr)
knitr::opts_chunk$set(
  collapse = TRUE,
  comment = "", 
  fig.width = 12, 
  fig.asp = 0.62
)
options(knitr.kable.NA = '')

Introduction

DNA evidence is the pre-eminent tool in the modern forensic scientists toolbox. It is widely accepted by the public, scientific and legal communities and it has been instrumental in determining both the innocence and guilt of individuals involved in the legal process. Despite this widespread acceptance there is unease regarding the statistical measures used to evaluate DNA evidence amongst some of members of all these communities. In particular, some people regard the random match probabilities associated with DNA evidence as just too small or basically unsupportable. In this vignette we discuss the basics of STR profiles, which serves as a reference for the package's other vignettes:

Matches and partial matches

Forensic genetics has its terminology which we briefly explain here. Human DNA consists of 23 pairs of chromosomes and those chromosomes are composed of a sequence of nucleotides which are labelled A, G, C and T after the bases adenine, guanine, cytosine and thymine that are used to form them. Modern DNA typing uses short tandem repeats (STRs). These are regions of DNA which are highly variable, but are patterned in that they consist of repeats of a short sequence of DNA bases. The locations at which this information is collected are called loci, and the (length) variations in the patterns observed at each locus are called alleles. We have two alleles at each locus, because humans are a diploid species, meaning they have two copies of each chromosome. One allele comes from our mother, and the other from our father.

A pair of alleles at a locus is called a genotype, and therefore a DNA profile is actually a multi-locus genotype. Modern forensic laboratories genotype DNA evidence using commercial kits, called multiplexes which consist of 9--17 loci. The multiplex currently used in the United Kingdom (and until recently New Zealand and Denmark) is called AmpFlSTR SGM Plus, or SGM Plus for short, and consists of 10 loci, plus one gender specific locus, Amelogenin. Forensic laboratories in the United States which load profiles into the FBI's Combined DNA Index System (CODIS) collect a core set of thirteen loci, although they are not constrained to use one multiplex.

STR_profile <- rbind(
  `**Locus:**` = c("vWA","D18","TH01","D2","D8","D3","FGA","D16","D21","D19"),
  `**Alleles:**` = c("15, 18", "14, 17",  "6, 9.3", "17, 23", "12, 15", "15, 15", "19, 23", "11, 12", "28, 28", "13, 14")
)
kable(STR_profile, caption = "A DNA profile from the SGM plus multiplex")

Table above shows a DNA profile from the SGM plus multiplex. There are two numbers at each locus representing the two alleles that make up the genotype at that locus. The numbers relate to the number of times the pattern or motif that describe the alleles at the locus are repeated. For example, this person's genotype at the locus TH01 is 6,9.3. This means that on one chromosome, the motif for TH01, TCAT was repeated 6 times, and on the other chromosome it was repeated 9 times, and then followed by TCA. The .3 represents the fact that three of the four bases have been repeated.

The DNAtools package

The aim of the DNAtools package is to provide statisticians and forensic scientists with access to the specific procedures described in the other vignettes. For example, for the database matching exercise (db_vignette), early implementations by @weir2004 and then @curran2007 required custom written code for each new database and, in the case of @curran2007, generation of at least half a dozen precursor files and a significant amount of memory. @tvedebrink2010; @tvedebrink2012 reduced the computational effort of @weir2004 and @curran2007 by deriving recursion formulas for the expectation and variance of the computed summary statistics. DNAtools aims to make all of these procedures easier to use in R.

Using the package DNAtools

library(DNAtools)
browseVignettes(package = "DNAtools")

In the listed vignettes the main features of the package are described, which allows statisticians and forensic scientists to easily examine the properties of a forensic DNA database. In particular, our package makes it simple to carry out a database comparison exercise where every DNA profile in the database is compared to every other database, and compare the resulting numbers of observed pairs of matching and partially matching profiles to expectation under a set of population genetic assumptions. Similarly, evaluating the distribution of the number of distinct alleles in high-order DNA mixtures is easily computed.

References


references: - id: brenner2007 author: - family: Brenner given: C title: Arizona DNA Database Matches. URL: http://dna-view.com/ArizonaMatch.htm issued: year: 2007 - id: budowle_1999 author: - family: Budowle given: B - family: Moretti given: TR title: Genotype Profiles for Six Population Groups at the 13 CODIS Short Tandem Repeat Core Loci and Other PCR-Based Loci. container-title: Forensic Science Communications 1(2). URL: http://www2.fbi.gov/hq/lab/fsc/backissu/july1999/budowle.htm issued: year: 1999 - id: curran2010 author: - family: Curran given: JM - family: Buckleton given: JS issued: year: 2010 title: Re Sign mistake in allele sharing probability formulae of Curran, et al. container-title: "Forensic Science International: Genetics, 4(3), 215--217." - id: curran2007 author: - family: Curran given: JM - family: Walsh given: SJ - family: Buckleton given: J issued: year: 2007 title: Empirical testing of estimated DNA frequencies. container-title: "Forensic Science International: Genetics, 1(3-4), 267--272." - id: Rsolnp author: - family: Ghalanos given: A - family: Theussl given: S issued: year: 2012 title: Rsolnp General Non-linear Optimization Using Augmented Lagrange Multiplier Method. container-title: R package version 1.16. - id: kaye2009 author: - family: Kaye given: DH issued: year: 2009 title: "Trawling DNA Databases for Partial Matches: What Is the FBI Afraid Of?" container-title: Cornell Journal of Law and Public Policy, 19(1) - id: mueller2008 author: - family: Mueller given: LD issued: year: 2008 title: Can simple population genetic models reconcile partial match frequencies observed in large forensic databases? container-title: Journal of Genetics, 87(2), 101--108. - id: troyer2001 author: - family: Troyer given: K - family: Gilboy T given: T - family: Koeneman given: B issued: year: 2001 title: A nine STR locus match between two apparently unrelated individuals using AmFlSTR Profiler Plus and Cofiler container-title: In Genetic Identity Conference Proceedings, 12th International Symposium on Human Identification. - id: tvedebrink2010 author: - family: Tvedebrink given: T issued: year: 2010 title: Statistical Aspects of Forensic Genetics -- Models for Qualitative and Quantitative STR Data. container-title: Ph.D. thesis, Department of Mathematical Sciences, Aalborg University. - id: tvedebrink2012 author: - family: Tvedebrink given: T - family: Eriksen given: PS - family: Curran given: JM - family: Mogensen given: HS - family: Morling given: N issued: year: 2012 title: Analysis of matches and partial-matches in a Danish DNA reference profile data set. container-title: "Forensic Science International: Genetics 6(3), 387-392." - id: weir2004 author: - family: Weir given: BS title: Matching and partially-matching DNA profiles. container-title: Journal of Forensic Sciences, 49(5), 1009--1014. issued: year: 2004 - id: weir2007 author: - family: Weir given: BS issued: year: 2007 title: The rarity of DNA Profiles. container-title: The Annals of Applied Statistics, 1(2), 358--370. - id: wiki_birthday author: Wikipedia issued: year: 2010 title: Birthday problem. URL: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birthday_problem




Try the DNAtools package in your browser

Any scripts or data that you put into this service are public.

DNAtools documentation built on July 8, 2020, 7:13 p.m.