Chan25: Corrected Misinformation and Correction Data from Chan and...

Chan25R Documentation

Corrected Misinformation and Correction Data from Chan and Albarracin (2023, 2025)

Description

Standardized mean differences and study characteristics from the corrected dataset accompanying Chan and Albarracin's meta-analysis of science-relevant misinformation. The name Chan25 refers to the 2025 Author Correction.

Format

A data frame with 207 observations on 30 variables and 75 distinct source PaperNumber identifiers.

rid

Source row identifier, stored as character data.

PaperNumber

Source report/study grouping identifier, stored as character data; decimal suffixes are retained.

Authors

Authors of the source report.

PubYear

Publication year of the source report.

ExpNum

Experiment number as supplied by the source authors.

SourceType

Publication category: published article (1), working paper (5), dissertation or thesis (6), or unpublished data (7).

RowNoteCond

Source notes identifying the experimental condition or comparison represented by the row.

BetweenWithin

Method of effect-size calculation: between-subjects (1) or within-subjects (2).

InPersonCorrect

Correction delivered in person (1) or not (-1).

LabOnline

Laboratory (1) or online (2) setting.

Nrow

Sample size assigned to the source row.

MeanAge

Mean participant age in years.

PctFemale

Female composition as supplied, usually a percentage; row r_86 is a proportion. See Details.

PctMale

Male composition as supplied, usually a percentage; row r_86 is a proportion. See Details.

NegMisinfo

Neutral (1) or negative (2) misinformation topic.

DetailedCorrect

Succinct (1) or detailed (2) correction.

LikelyFamiliar

Topic likely familiar (1) or unfamiliar (-1).

DomainMisinfo

Misinformation domain: politics (1), health (2), environment (3), or other (-1).

FictIssue

Fictitious (1) or real (-1) issue.

IssuePolarize

Politically polarizing (1) or non-polarizing (-1) topic in the country of the experiment.

USOther

United States (1) or other-country (2) sample.

AttCongenial

Correction congenial to prior attitudes (1), or incongruent/non-partisan (-1).

es1.g

Bias-adjusted standardized mean difference for correction, as supplied by the source authors.

es2.g

Reversed misinformation-persistence effect, as stored in the source data and labelled in the source analysis code.

es1.gv

Supplied sampling variance of es1.g.

es2.gv

Supplied sampling variance of es2.g.

mis.g

Bias-adjusted standardized mean difference for misinformation, before imputation.

mis.gv

Supplied sampling variance of mis.g.

impmis.g

Misinformation effect used in the source analysis including imputed values.

impmis.gv

Supplied variance associated with impmis.g; missing values are retained.

Details

The data retain all rows, variable names, missing values, and numeric values from the first worksheet of meta-scirelmisinfo_v20240320.xlsx. No effect sizes, variances, or moderator codes are recalculated or imputed. Row r_86 stores PctFemale and PctMale as proportions (0.6081632653 and 0.3918367347), whereas the other rows use percentages. These entries are retained unchanged. Yousuf et al. (2021), Table 1, report 596 female participants among 980 in total, confirming that the female entry is already a proportion. Analyses requiring proportions must account for this difference in units rather than divide every entry by 100. The primary report is available at \Sexpr[results=rd]{tools:::Rd_expr_doi("10.1016/j.eclinm.2021.100881")}.

The 207 wide-format rows contain 156 correction effects and 89 reversed misinformation-persistence effects, giving 245 effects in total.

Several rows share a PaperNumber; rows must not be assumed independent. The identifier is retained as character data. Sampling covariances between mis.g and es1.g are not supplied. A working correlation used for robust variance estimation in the source analysis does not establish this sampling covariance. Sample sizes may recur across rows and should not be summed as counts of distinct participants.

Source

Chan, M.-P. S., & Albarracin, D. (2023). A meta-analysis of correction effects in science-relevant misinformation. Nature Human Behaviour, 7(9), 1514–1525. \Sexpr[results=rd]{tools:::Rd_expr_doi("10.1038/s41562-023-01623-8")}

Chan, M.-P. S., & Albarracin, D. (2025). Author Correction: A meta-analysis of correction effects in science-relevant misinformation. Nature Human Behaviour, 9(9), 1992–1994. \Sexpr[results=rd]{tools:::Rd_expr_doi("10.1038/s41562-025-02294-3")}

Data and analysis code: https://osf.io/vkygw/. Source spreadsheet: meta-scirelmisinfo_v20240320.xlsx, first worksheet, obtained on 19 October 2026.

Examples

data(Chan25)
dim(Chan25)
head(Chan25[c("rid", "PaperNumber", "es1.g", "es1.gv", "mis.g", "mis.gv")])

## Complete rows for regression of correction on misinformation
vars <- c("PaperNumber", "es1.g", "es1.gv", "mis.g", "mis.gv")
dat <- Chan25[complete.cases(Chan25[vars]), vars]
nrow(dat)
length(unique(dat$PaperNumber))

metaSEM documentation built on Nov. 16, 2026, 5:07 p.m.