inst/examples/marginalLikelihoodHelp.R

##############################################################
# Comparison of ML for two regression models

# Creating test data with quadratic relationship
sampleSize = 30
x <- (-(sampleSize-1)/2):((sampleSize-1)/2)
y <-  1 * x + 1*x^2 + rnorm(n=sampleSize,mean=0,sd=10)
# plot(x,y, main="Test Data")

# likelihoods for linear and quadratic model 
likelihood1 <- function(param){
  pred = param[1] + param[2]*x + param[3] * x^2
  singlelikelihoods = dnorm(y, mean = pred, sd = 1/(param[4]^2), log = TRUE)
  return(sum(singlelikelihoods))  
}
likelihood2 <- function(param){
  pred = param[1] + param[2]*x 
  singlelikelihoods = dnorm(y, mean = pred, sd = 1/(param[3]^2), log = TRUE)
  return(sum(singlelikelihoods))  
}

setUp1 <- createBayesianSetup(likelihood1, 
                              lower = c(-5,-5,-5,0.01), 
                              upper = c(5,5,5,30))
setUp2 <- createBayesianSetup(likelihood2, 
                              lower = c(-5,-5,0.01), 
                              upper = c(5,5,30))

out1 <- runMCMC(bayesianSetup = setUp1)
M1 = marginalLikelihood(out1, start = 1000)

out2 <- runMCMC(bayesianSetup = setUp2)
M2 = marginalLikelihood(out2, start = 1000)


### Calculating Bayes factor

exp(M1$ln.ML - M2$ln.ML)

# BF > 1 means the evidence is in favor of M1. See Kass, R. E. & Raftery, A. E. 
# (1995) Bayes Factors. J. Am. Stat. Assoc., Amer Statist Assn, 90, 773-795.

### Calculating Posterior weights

exp(M1$ln.ML) / ( exp(M1$ln.ML) + exp(M2$ln.ML))

# If models have different model priors, multiply with the prior probabilities of each model. 


\dontrun{ 
#############################################################
# Fractional Bayes factor

# Motivation: ML is very dependent on the prior, which is a problem if you 
# have uninformative priors. you can see this via rerunning the upper  
# example with changed priors - suddenly, support for M1 is gone


setUp1 <- createBayesianSetup(likelihood1, 
                              lower = c(-500,-500,-500,0.01), 
                              upper = c(500,500,500,3000))
setUp2 <- createBayesianSetup(likelihood2, 
                              lower = c(-500,-500,0.01), 
                              upper = c(500,500,3000))

out1 <- runMCMC(bayesianSetup = setUp1)
M1 = marginalLikelihood(out1, start = 1000)

out2 <- runMCMC(bayesianSetup = setUp2)
M2 = marginalLikelihood(out2, start = 1000)


### Calculating Bayes factor

exp(M1$ln.ML - M2$ln.ML)

# it has therefore been suggested that ML should not be calculated on uninformative priors. But
# what to do if there are no informative priors?
# one option is to calculate the fractional BF, which means that one splites the data in half,
# uses the first half to fit the model, and then use the posterior as a new (now informative)
# prior for the ML - let's do this for the previous case


# likelihoods with half the data 
likelihood1 <- function(param){
  pred = param[1] + param[2]*x + param[3] * x^2
  singlelikelihoods = dnorm(y, mean = pred, sd = 1/(param[4]^2), log = TRUE)
  return(sum(singlelikelihoods[seq(1, 30, 2)]))  
}
likelihood2 <- function(param){
  pred = param[1] + param[2]*x 
  singlelikelihoods = dnorm(y, mean = pred, sd = 1/(param[3]^2), log = TRUE)
  return(sum(singlelikelihoods[seq(1, 30, 2)]))  
}

setUp1 <- createBayesianSetup(likelihood1, 
                              lower = c(-500,-500,-500,0.01), 
                              upper = c(500,500,500,3000))
setUp2 <- createBayesianSetup(likelihood2, 
                              lower = c(-500,-500,0.01), 
                              upper = c(500,500,3000))

out1 <- runMCMC(bayesianSetup = setUp1)
out2 <- runMCMC(bayesianSetup = setUp2)

newPrior1 = createPriorDensity(out1, start = 200, 
                               lower = c(-500,-500,-500,0.01), 
                               upper = c(500,500,500,3000))
newPrior2 = createPriorDensity(out2, start = 200, 
                               lower = c(-500,-500,0.01), 
                               upper = c(500,500,3000))

# now rerun this with likelihoods for the other half of the data and new prior

likelihood1 <- function(param){
  pred = param[1] + param[2]*x + param[3] * x^2
  singlelikelihoods = dnorm(y, mean = pred, sd = 1/(param[4]^2), log = TRUE)
  return(sum(singlelikelihoods[seq(2, 30, 2)]))  
}
likelihood2 <- function(param){
  pred = param[1] + param[2]*x 
  singlelikelihoods = dnorm(y, mean = pred, sd = 1/(param[3]^2), log = TRUE)
  return(sum(singlelikelihoods[seq(2, 30, 2)]))  
}

setUp1 <- createBayesianSetup(likelihood1, prior = newPrior1)
setUp2 <- createBayesianSetup(likelihood2, prior = newPrior2)

out1 <- runMCMC(bayesianSetup = setUp1)
M1 = marginalLikelihood(out1, start = 1000)

out2 <- runMCMC(bayesianSetup = setUp2)
M2 = marginalLikelihood(out2, start = 1000)

### Calculating the fractional Bayes factor

exp(M1$ln.ML - M2$ln.ML)

}

############################################################
### Performance comparison ### 


# Low dimensional case with narrow priors - all methods have low error

# we use a truncated normal for the likelihood to make sure that the density 
# integrates to 1 - makes it easier to calcuate the theoretical ML
likelihood <- function(x) sum(msm::dtnorm(x, log = TRUE, lower = -1, upper = 1))
prior = createUniformPrior(lower = rep(-1,2), upper = rep(1,2))
bayesianSetup <- createBayesianSetup(likelihood = likelihood, prior = prior)
out = runMCMC(bayesianSetup = bayesianSetup, settings = list(iterations = 5000))

# plot(out)

# theoretical value
theory = log(1/(2^2))

marginalLikelihood(out)$ln.ML - theory
marginalLikelihood(out, method = "Prior", numSamples =  500)$ln.ML - theory
marginalLikelihood(out, method = "HM", numSamples =  500)$ln.ML - theory
marginalLikelihood(out, method = "Bridge", numSamples =  500)$ln.ML - theory


# higher dimensions - wide prior - HM and Prior don't work

likelihood <- function(x) sum(msm::dtnorm(x, log = TRUE, lower = -10, upper = 10))
prior = createUniformPrior(lower = rep(-10,3), upper = rep(10,3))
bayesianSetup <- createBayesianSetup(likelihood = likelihood, prior = prior)
out = runMCMC(bayesianSetup = bayesianSetup, settings = list(iterations = 5000))

# plot(out)

# theoretical value
theory = log(1/(20^3))

marginalLikelihood(out)$ln.ML - theory
marginalLikelihood(out, method = "Prior", numSamples =  500)$ln.ML - theory
marginalLikelihood(out, method = "HM", numSamples =  500)$ln.ML - theory
marginalLikelihood(out, method = "Bridge", numSamples =  500)$ln.ML - theory

Try the BayesianTools package in your browser

Any scripts or data that you put into this service are public.

BayesianTools documentation built on Dec. 10, 2019, 1:08 a.m.